If you have not seen Doctor Who: The End of Time Parts 1 & 2, please come back to visit after you have seen it as this post contains spoilers.
!!!SPOILERS!!!
Just wow.
I didn’t expect such an emotional roller coaster. The End of Time made me cry. I actually felt loss.
I think I sulked for about an hour before I could put together some thoughts about WHY this episode was so powerful.
Events that lead to the death of the Tenth Doctor have been carefully crafted for over a year. The clues about his death were blatant. Nothing was a surprise which is why the emotional reaction that I had to The End of Time caught me off guard.
The Doctor has been pretty open about his will to live and his love of life. The tantrum that he throws when he figures out that the guy that knocks four times isn’t the Master but Wilfred, Donna’s dad, is incredible. He, like The Master, misinterprets “prophecy” and it ends badly for both of them. The Doctor isn’t shy about expressing his disappointment that a lowly nobody is the reason that he is going to die. Earlier, he tries to figure out why Wilfred is always around; why him, why was he so special? The Doctor has this tantrum out loud in front of Wilfred. It was something that we never see. It is customary for heroes to tighten their jaw and face their fate with honor. Not our Doctor. It wasn’t cowardly but different and it is part of the reason that makes his departure so painful. The exact spot where my package of Puffs Plus started to get lighter is the scene where The Doctor is glowing and is about to disperse. He, out in the cold of space, alone, knows what’s coming and practically whimpers, “I don’t want to die.” I lost it. It was too much, too good, well done, bravo, please take my money.
I don’t recall being this emotional when Christopher Eccleston left the show. I do remember fussing about it in spurts for about a year. You can still get me to go on a good rant about him every once in awhile. He was my first Doctor, your first is always special but like life, it’s not always the first one that gets your heart… watch out for the second one. I think I’m taking it so hard because I didn’t really want David Tennant. I liked him well enough but he had to really work to win me over. Even after he did, I’d still yammer on about Christopher Eccleston who really didn’t care for the role at all. David Tennant was THE Doctor of my generation. He owned the role and gave us a lot. He gave us 4 years of adventure and fun. Thank you David Tennant.
——————-
This isn’t really a review so I’ll keep the rest of my thoughts short. I will go into greater detail on my podcast Sci-Fi Party Line. Keep a look out for that episode sometime next week.
Martha and Mickey Married?: I didn’t really see that one coming but I don’t mind it. Mickey grew up a lot over the course of the years. To see him fighting aliens with Martha is awesome! That should be the next Doctor Who spin-off! The Adventures of Martha and Mickey!
I’m a little bummed that The Time Lords were evil in this story. I guess because I haven’t watched the old Who shows, I didn’t get that the Time Lords were evil. I’ve always thought of them as noble beings. I want to see them noble again. If they are recurring bad guys, I guess I wouldn’t mind that either. My ulterior motive is that I love their costumes and want to see them walking about more. Timothy Dalton as Lord President is kinda hot. I have a small crush on him and I’m slightly uncomfortable admitting it. Let’s not discuss it further. [Update: Good lord, the man is 63! You still got it.]
The Master’s plan to make everyone like him was stupid. It was the weakest part of the whole story. It let it go because the guy is crazy and crazy people do crazy crap. I wanted to fear The Master and not just think of him as some retarded Time Lord jester reject. It sucks that the Time Lords made him that way so that they could use him for their own selfish purposes. To belittle and reject him because he was defective at their own hands was very low. Dunno… maybe I have to accept that The Time Lords are just a bunch of douche bags. Doctor Ten was getting a little d-baggy in his old age so maybe it’s for the best that he’s the last one.
Matt Smith – Doctor Eleven: While weeping into my tissues, I found myself not caring about anything he was doing. Because I was in mourning, my initial reaction was that he did too much for a first appearance. He was cracking jokes about being a female, still not being ginger, etc. These things would have been perfect for the next episode. It would give him a chance to shine on his own. Because I was numb, seeing wackiness at the end of this episode felt like overkill.
We’ll see if time heals all wounds.
I just watched it. I lost it when Wilfred started crying saying goodbye to him at Donna’s wedding. I liked it. RTD usually tries to fit everybody in to these things and it takes away from the story. Here he used the people he wanted, but always keeping the focus on The Doctor. Martha knew what was happening, that he wasn’t coming back, and of course so did Sarah Jane. She just had to look at his posture and she began welling up. This was the 4th version of him she’s met, and she really liked this version.
I agree with you 100% about how he went out. He did read the prophecy wrongly and it cost him his life. He wasn’t cowardly. He was just really po’d at himself and fate and time that he would die like this, for a mortal of little historical consequence and one he truly respected and loved.
About the Time Lords. They were never evil (well I guess they became very morally questionable during the Time War), but always imperious, pompous, condescending and always looking for ways around the limits they had imposed on themselves as the protectors of Time. The way The Doctor acted in Water of Mars was very much the way they were. The Doctor was banished for objecting to their ways and for just wanting to explore. They punished him at first by stranding him on Earth, then not allowing him full control of the TARDIS then by giving him a Time Lord with a stick up her rear as a companion (Romana I)
Eventually they reconciled when The Doctor helped stop a mad President (a couple of times). They made him the Lord President, eventually he resigned but kept his title and his vote in the council. Find the Tom Baker serial The Deadly Assassin! I think it makes much more sense when The Doctor reveals the President to be Rassilon. Think Surak of Vulcan or Kahless of Klingon. The first Time Lord. Now twisted by the war and determined to preserve his Time Lords at the expense of the rest of creation. The Doctor and a companion had left Rassilon in a timeless Divergent universe, trapped in a permanent loop. I guess he got out. I would guess that the mysterious woman was either his granddaughter who was the first Doctor’s companion or his mother (I’m sure someone will wiki an answer this week).
Amazing post! Thanks for this!
Helps explain some things. Believe it or not, I’m going to watch it again. I rarely watch episodes twice.
@serienjunkies BBC plant neuen Studiokomplex in Wales http://4sj.de/dpg #DoctorWho
@Podshock: Matt Smith rejected for BBC’s ‘Sherlock’ | Digital Spy http://ow.ly/146Zy #doctorwho #mattsmith